Search This Blog

Friday, January 21, 2011

Coloring with reflection orbits

Here are the 24 distinct  four-color colorings of the vertices of a square:


The squares in each one of the six blocks are reflection orbits. These orbits form a partition of the full set of colorings, or, equivalently, a partition of the set of all permutations of  four distinct colors. Can you identify the six orbits?

Last revised 02/02/2011
These  postings are based on "Symmetry Studies An  Introduction to the Analysis of Structured Data in Applications"  Cambridge Press (2008)

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Reflections and reflection orbits

Reflections are very useful mechanisms to express symmetry relations among objects, images, ideas, narratives, poems, lyrics, melodies, movements, arguments, molecules, and many more.

The squares shown below illustrate the mechanism of line reflections.


Select any one of the squares. Can you then identify the square that is its image by a vertical line of reflection? Next, identify the other square that is its image by an horizontal line of reflection.  Now observe that the remaining square is the image of the originally selected one by:

  • Iterating the two reflections (in any order) or;
  • Directly rotating it (by 180 degrees).

Thus, it seems that here the iteration of two line reflections (with 90 degrees of separation) produces the same effect of a (planar 180 degree) rotation of the original square.

Let's indicate these symmetry operations with the letters:

v to indicate a reflection relative to a vertical line;
h to indicate a reflection relative to a horizontal  line;
o to indicate a double-reflection or the 180-degree central rotation.


You will observe that it really does not matter which square you select as your starting point: after applying  the reflections and double-reflections to that initial square you will always end up with the same set. This set is called an orbit of symmetry. We say that the orbit has the symmetry of those reflections and their iterations. To include the starting square in the orbit we add a transformation that just leaves any object as is. We call it the identity transformation, and write it as 1.

Together, then, the set of transformations, that we write as

D_2 = {1, v, h, o},

generates the reflection orbits. Shortly, we say that the resulting orbits have the symmetry of D_2.

In the Flag Experiment each row of flags is an orbit with the symmetry of D_2.


Last revised 02/02/2011
06/06/06
These  postings are based on "Symmetry Studies An  Introduction to the Analysis of Structured Data in Applications"  Cambridge Press (2008)










Saturday, January 8, 2011

Symmetry that now you see and now you don't.

Symmetry is an elusive concept. Blaise Pascal (Pensées, 1660, Article I,  Fragment 28) captured its elusiveness when he stated that

Symmetry is what we see at a glance...

The following images carry, in my opinion, this essential, practical, aspect of symmetry - its having and having not of something. For the moment I invite you to just appreciate them, perhaps with Pascal's words in the back of your mind.

The images are from ornamental fringes around the Panagia Gorgoepíkoös ("Our Lady Who Swiftly Hears") church, also known as Agios Eleftherios. It is a small 12th-century church in the Pláka district, in central Athens, Greece. The church is also known as the Mikrí Mitropolí (Little Cathedral), since it is located next to the neighboring Mitrópoli.





Last revised 01/26/2011
These  postings are based on "Symmetry Studies An  Introduction to the Analysis of Structured Data in Applications"  Cambridge Press (2008)

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Visual Perception of Symmetry - I

Here



are the 24 possible 4-color colorings of flags with that particular rectangular design. The experiment, conducted among 15 undergraduate students during the Spring semester (2011), consisted of a two-step choice process:

[1] In each row of the above figure, choose the flag you like the most, and record its label (A,B,C, or D);
[2] choose the flags that are the most similar to your first choice and order them subsequently, so that the flag falling in the last position seems the least similar to your first favorite choice.

For example, if in a given row the favorite flag was in column B, followed by the flags in columns D, C, and A then that row gets the ordering B, D, C, A. Each student ranked all six rows in the figure above.

We will look at the results of this experiment in the light of symmetry arguments. I invite you to conduct the experiment with your colleagues, and perhaps share your results with us.

Last revised 02/23/2011
These  postings are based on "Symmetry Studies An  Introduction to the Analysis of Structured Data in Applications"  Cambridge Press (2008)